On Womanhood
Apr. 25th, 2022 07:58 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
My relationship to my own femininity has always been complicated, to make the personal understatement of the century. As a child, I was torn between wanting to be "natural", i.e. a tomboy, which was in direct conflict with the urge to be a perfect princess with clean fingernails and well-behaved hair.
It's not easier to be a male or a female in this world. Both genders come with a long list of benefits and drawbacks. Confusion arises when people expect what's good for the goose to be automatically bad for the gander. For instance, the same sexism that traps a would be Amazon warrior at home is the tendency to protect the most fragile and precious members of society from being pregnant while blown to smithereens on the battlefield. Women are simply better or worse at some things than men when we acknowledge the immutable laws of limits.
The Inability to Discriminate
The inability to discriminate is a common end-of-empire phenomenon. It's a way of throwing all caution to the wind until you forget what it was you were being cautious about in the first place. All areas of the political spectrum participate in the inability to discriminate. For the affluent leftist, they do it by sending their children to corporatist indoctrination camps known as "schools" until their child suffers a list of dysmorphias-du-jour and spends countless hours in the psychotherapist's chair in a half-hearted attempt to remedy their misery. It's the same "more is better" initiative that causes right wing Christians to build brutalist faith factories complete with multi-million dollar sound systems and lighting setups when their God was a homeless champion of the poor.
The latest vogue is to apply the inability to discriminate when it comes to gender, that thing that made me a female back when I was being born to a 22 year old Japanese American woman in a Salvation Army medical center in 1973.
It's In the Hips
Gender is not a minor thing. Scientists can dig up fossilized bones from tens of thousands of years ago and determine if the person was male or female. Females have different bones, especially our hips, which are larger because they were designed to help us carry babies. As someone who didn't want to have children in this incarnation and who had myself sterilized in my early 30s to prevent any chance of procreation, I don't like the fact I have ample hips. I would have preferred the prevalent slim hips of an 80s movie star. When Sir Mix-A-Lot came out with his song Baby Got Back in 1992, it had me squealing in laughter as suddenly all my body dysmorphia about my big butt was put into a wildly unthinkable perspective. I had terrible dysmorphia issues about my face as well. All of my female friends had dysmorphia issues with very few exceptions. To be female in the end of the 20th century was to live cheek to jowl with dysmorphia. Every girlfriend I had was at least mildly if not severely anorexic by high school. Yet beauty is entirely in the eye of the beholder. One person's svelte is the next's emaciated. One's giant nose is another's ancestral sculpture. And there's also that inconvenient reality that looks are not everything...
Red Tide
Of course I had to get my period shortly after my twelfth birthday and of course it had to happen on the softball field during school. Be careful what you wish for! I have an unfortunate (or fortunate?) talent not to be able to do anything half-assed, and my period was a red tide from the bowels of hell. Think the Kubrick version of The Shining's elevator scene. At age 33, I would regularly turn green from pain and double over in the fetal position if I didn't preemptively swallow four Advil. Back then, one was supposed to suck it up and ignore the pain in order to get good grades. I wasn't able to get good grades with ease, so missing school would have meant academic failure worse than the D's and C's I often pulled in my senior year of high school. Now in hindsight I realize I should have been completely out of school four to six days a month just to deal with my period. Instead I went to the school bathroom every hour to change my soaked dressings for six years, then four more when I went to college, when it happily slowed down to changing once every 3-4 hours. Yes, this means at night I had to wake up every hour to change my pad and later on my tampon and pad, and to re-medicate with Advil, which was the only thing that worked. Anyone who says it is easy to be born female or who romanticizes being born female should consider what having a heavy, painful period every month will be like, because the gods have a funny habit of teaching us lessons the hard way.
I no longer have my period. I don't miss it, but I do miss my young womanhood which seemed to thoroughly depart just as my beloved cat Kiki died at age 15. I miss the old Kimberly's mojo, her ability to embrace the spontaneous, and her scathing wit that came from a place of blackened nihilism. This new Kimberly is not the same. She is more cautious and less quick to judge, but also more timid and less tolerant of thoroughly dissenting views.
Motherhood
When I was looking for my Japanese birthmother in my early 30s, I ran face-first into the crapfest of female exploitation and misogyny that plagues Western culture. My birthmother did not provide her name. It was only through careful sleuthing and a few lucky breaks that I found out her information. My original birth certificate was conveniently lost even though I was promised all of my young life that I would have access to it upon turning eighteen. I was born into an adoption mill. My parents bought me for about sixty grand, which was an absolute fortune in 1973. My birthmother was one of the only unwed mothers in the baby mill who eagerly surrendered her parental rights, hoping never to be found or contacted again. The other birthing moms, most only in their teens unlike my mom, gave away their babies with horror and sadness. One birthmom who later became my friend spent years trying to find her daughter only to be rejected and turned away. As a child of one of society's harlots, I had no rights to my own family name or my genetic predispositions. The birthmom who had her baby at age 16 and later overcame hell and high water to find her, only to be rejected, also had no rights. She was a "slut" who had been too easy and had let her boyfriend at the time have his way with her. Of course he disappeared once she was pregnant and had to be shunted off to a city a thousand miles away to have his shame baby. Adoption mills do not exist in cultures that love and respect women and girls.
The fear of getting pregnant was a cross I bore from the age of twelve until thirty-three when I had myself sterilized. I spent my entire young womanhood terrified of pregnancy. At no time did I ever want to become pregnant. I didn't fear becoming pregnant because I would be a bad mother; I feared becoming pregnant because I would have no choice but to become a good one. I still feel that anyone who would force a woman to carry a baby to term against her will is a disgusting barbarian unworthy of the freedoms he or she enjoys. Never once do these types admit that it's about controlling the female who carries the baby, not the actual baby. The proof is in the pudding when it comes to providing a viable support network for young, single women that does not cast them into generational cycles of vicious poverty.
As @mikevyers said on his banned, deleted, Streisand Effect-viral TikTok Dr. Phil video when addressing some bearded M-to-F crossdressers:
"What you want to do is appropriate women. You appropriate womanhood and then basically turn it into a costume that can be worn."
Exactly. You don't get to take billions of years of planetary biology and pretend the pain of menstruation and childbirth never happened. You don't just erase the for-profit baby mills of the last few centuries. You don't get to pretend little boys have the same media-implanted dysmorphic images in their heads as little girls. You don't get to erase the soul-disintegrating terror of what it is to have sex or be raped and get pregnant as a result. You don't get to pretend you understand the mind-rending pain of miscarriage. You don't get to pretend you're a female just so you can win a series of absolutely meaningless accolades for Best Swimmer like William "Lia" Thomas. You don't get to pretend that several major religions didn't bar all those with your genital set from all roles other than pretty little f**k machine, baby factory, and housekeeper. And at least if you're going to appropriate womanhood, shave off the goddamn beard and mustache, you pathetic, lazy, weak-minded poseur. Yikes... I guess the old Kimberly is back for the moment!
Yay the old Kimberly
Date: 2022-04-26 04:54 am (UTC)Annette
Maybe more later……
Re: Yay the old Kimberly
Date: 2022-04-26 05:48 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-04-26 07:24 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-04-26 05:48 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-04-26 01:36 pm (UTC)I'm a Gen X-er too, born a couple of years after you. Midway through high school my hips swung wide while the rest of me stayed thin. I still struggle with it, though I should know better. I went on diets hoping to shrink the hips and shed the pounds my hormones deemed necessary around hips and thighs. Zero luck. The ideal female shape chosen by our culture seems designed to inflict maximum female frustration (big bust, tiny waist, no hips but curvy butt. Big bouncy hair on the head while being hairless everywhere else). Why?
I learned very young to be afraid of male violence. Then as a teenager, I would go for walks to relieve stress and adult men would drive by staring at my body like a piece of meat. Even though I'm nothing like the ideal female and didn't dress in an attention getting way. There are lots of ways women cope with this...my way was to attempt invisibility and hypervigilance.
Some drag queens seem to be exploring femininity and I have no problem with that. They're more than welcome to my share of makeup and uncomfortable clothes. But some of them seem determined to take what is worst about women and amplify it, acting shrill, shallow, hysterical. OK, some women are, and a little good natured critique is fair. But until they've walked a mile in our horrendous heels, I don't want to hear it!
Many of the women I know in my age group didn't have children. I was terrified of pregnancy and childbirth too. That's something I often wonder about.
I'm glad old Kimberly came out to say a few things.
Pschedelic jocular puca
no subject
Date: 2022-04-26 06:14 pm (UTC)As for male violence, it's the thing that makes males the inferior sex, in my opinion. I'm finally passing out of the age where I'm looked at as a piece of meat, but it happens regularly enough that I have to be vigilant whenever I'm out in public.
Drag queens don't seem to be as problematic as the bearded idiots in the Mike Vyers video, unless it's that small set trying to normalize the sexualization of children a la Drag Queen Story Hour. The last drag queen show I attended didn't even allow children because it was in a bar in Chicago. If we could all return to a sensible set of boundaries, i.e. no children allowed at drag queen shows because they are boozy and the humor is aimed at the sexually mature, that would be great.
Finally I have come full circle and realize that my fears of pregnancy were most likely my karma from previous lives. It's not that I was afraid of pregnancy on the physical side -- whatever, I'm very strong and if it was only a physical matter, I could have popped out several kids. I didn't want the responsibility of being a good mother.
no subject
Date: 2022-04-27 12:26 pm (UTC)It has often seemed to me that to be born female is to be trapped. We are often forced into subservient roles by violence and threats of violence. Forced to mute self-expression lest we draw the wrong kind of attention. Trapped by monthly cycles that range from inconvenient to painful. And before widespread birth control, trapped in constant cycles of pregnancy and childbirth. The culture here in the US is unhealthy is many ways but it also offered women a little breathing room from those cycles. My gratitude goes out to all those women who fought to improve our lives.
I clicked on that bathwater link. Yuck on so many levels! Sad too.
Psychedelic jocular puca
no subject
Date: 2022-04-27 07:05 pm (UTC)Trans in the 90s
Date: 2022-04-26 06:05 pm (UTC)I worked for a biotech company in Seattle in the 1990s. One of the guys in IT, a very feminine man, decided to transition. This was back when there was quite a process to accomplish this: Medical counseling, Mental Health counseling, secure a designated "unisex" restroom at work for many months, and ultimately, gender reassignment surgery in Canada, as that was not an option in the US.
"Elaine" did it all. The entire company, to the best of my knowledge, was happy to refer to her as a her, because she was such a sincere, kind, unassuming person. In effect, it seemed she'd earned it.
Fast forward to today, and just wow! The sense of entitlement blows my mind. These men are not women. They never will be. Elaine understood that, and by all appearances was fine with that. She just wanted to live a modest life as an honorary member of the tribe.
I sure hope that's how it's turned out for her.
Valerie
Re: Trans in the 90s
Date: 2022-04-26 06:15 pm (UTC)Re: Trans in the 90s
Date: 2022-04-28 12:11 am (UTC)Valerie
Re: Trans in the 90s
Date: 2022-04-29 01:08 am (UTC)Re: Trans in the 90s
Date: 2022-04-27 07:06 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-04-26 06:46 pm (UTC)Sometimes I think back to how much of my life I spent absolutely terrified that I would get pregnant (and therefore was never in a situation to become pregnant until my 20s, though it could have happened without my consent at any time, of course). Then, after having kids, I mysteriously went through menopause around age 35 and mourned no longer being able to get pregnant, even though I didn't want any more kids. There is a tremendous emotional journey tied up with female or male physicality that is quite different from the emotional journey of someone who is transgender.
no subject
Date: 2022-04-27 01:33 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-04-26 07:46 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-04-27 01:33 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-04-26 10:36 pm (UTC)My periods were painful, I know all about the preemptive ibuprofen! I don't miss them at all, either and was blessed with a relatively easy menopause..it gradually faded and one day just stopped.
I think the trans agenda is an attack on the sacred feminine by the creatures that really run this planet. It is a mockery. And the strong female athletes must stand together in their refusal to participate or it will never end. But everyone is so afraid of being called names! !!
Colleen
no subject
Date: 2022-04-27 01:46 am (UTC)I too have zero libido. I wish this could have happened back when it would have been useful, for instance at age 18 where I needed most to study and get extra sleep. Youth is wasted on the young.
I am planning on writing an essay on how female appropriation has become yet another avenue for the tired, ancient tradition of male violence. One thing that always pissed me off was the way men dominate the field of cuisine (glorified cooking). Women have always been saddled with cooking throughout the ages, yet men get all the glory for it. They're the ones who sit in the exam rooms at the Sorbonne, who get their own TV shows like Iron Chef, and who run the restaurant chains. This trend of attempting to replace women is more of the same -- "We'll out-woman the women!" Except this isn't cooking. You are 1.born with a womb, 2.born with penis and balls, or 3.you're a tiny percentage that is defective/malformed in some key respect. This tiny percentage has neither or a bit of both, and in that case, it's typical to have more womanly characteristics like XXY.
no subject
Date: 2022-04-27 02:55 am (UTC)I'm of the blue collar tribe and we eat blue collar food.
And this brings to mind the food pyramid that you mentioned before. I remember that too. And even when I was young and time didn't seem so tight I thought " Who has the time to eat all of this damned food every day??" Your whole entire day would literally revolve around thinking about, preparing and eating so much food!
no subject
Date: 2022-04-27 07:15 pm (UTC)As for the food pyramid, there used to be a nutrition tracking app called Chronometer and it would inform me of how lacking my diet happened to be in vitamins and minerals. Basically the only way to get enough nutrition according to the app is to eat kale salad with oil free dressing seven large meals per day. I love me some kale salad but nobody can live up to Chronometer's requirements without being utterly obsessed with food. I think Chronometer and the FDA accidentally reveal how much etheric depletion affects food. No matter how many clean calories you jam in your face, there's no keeping up with the modern devitalization of food.
no subject
Date: 2022-04-26 11:54 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-04-27 01:46 am (UTC)Well Said
Date: 2022-04-27 05:11 am (UTC)Well said, nice druid lady. I confer upon you, by the authority vested in me by the gods of the imageboards and their wandering truth seekers, the title of Absolutely Based and Redpilled. May you be blessed with feminine strength, grace and wisdom.
Re: Well Said
Date: 2022-04-27 07:17 pm (UTC)LOL I also had to look up "based" in Urban Dictionary because I'm a Gen X fossil.
Preach Sister!
Date: 2022-04-27 01:13 pm (UTC)As a gay man (in my mid-fifties) who grew up in a lower middle class American household, I sometimes feel I've been (or more truthfully, allowed myself to be....) hood-winked into blindly following the narrative du jour. Anyone remember the slogan "hate is not a family value" circa 1990? I thought I was soooo hip wearing a tee shirt with that blazoned on it while flying across the continent back in 1992. Naturally I had a red Aids ribbon pinned to my shirt as well. What a fool was I.
I take small comfort in remembering the expression (Churchill, I believe): "If you're not liberal when young, you have no heart and if you're not conservative when old, you have no brain."
When I look at the person in the tiktok video all I can think is: "Well I was cast in the roles of understudy for JC of Nazareth as well as Mary Mag in my campus production of Godspell and I want to make sure I am ready for either one!"
Thanks Kimberly for the article and the opportunity to pause and think....
Re: Preach Sister!
Date: 2022-04-27 07:23 pm (UTC)That's an epic Godspell reference! Love it.
no subject
Date: 2022-04-29 03:32 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-04-30 04:38 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2022-05-04 07:31 am (UTC)https://youtu.be/r0sVo8dQkuc
I'd say it makes my blood boil, but that has happened so much my veins have adapted into high pressure steam pipes.
no subject
Date: 2022-04-29 07:13 pm (UTC)There is one absolutely banned middle grades author at my home. Bet you can guess which: the one who made a big deal out of how mild and cool periods are.
I disagree with you about the purpose of abortion in our culture: the purpose, as I see it, is to make women's bodies available for sex with men without consequences. No brother or father showing up with a shotgun to make him "do the right thing", no state mandated child support (the modern version of the shotgun marriage's purpose). Birth control, abortion, she has no reason not to be sexually available. I think we see this with the demand that lesbians be available for sex with pre-transition MtF as well. I mean, seriously, not wanting to should be an acceptable and final answer for anyone, and it's no one's business why not.
Of course, being a Christian, I believe abortion is murder and support crisis pregnancy charities, so we'll disagree on what abortion is, but do you think I'm so very far off on the making women available for sex side? I think it does tie in with the sexualization of young girls and the constant portrayal of women as sex objects at all times. I knew a lot of girls who felt like they had to have sex and found it unpleasant and unfulfilling as teens. As an adult by my first time, I found it fun, and suspect my friends would have been much better served to wait until their rather stupid and mostly transient boyfriends matured a little!
BoysMom
P.S. Accidentaly hit post comment while typing. This is the same comment, less a case error and with the entirety of the last two sentences.
no subject
Date: 2022-04-30 04:34 am (UTC)I never realized how overrated the aforementioned author was until I read her book Wifey as an adult. Ick. She should have stuck with cutesy Junior Room lit.
I had not thought of it that way. You have a good point. I do agree with you that abortion and birth control are extremely useful tools in ensuring that women are at least always perceived as being available for sex. I was terrified of having to obtain an abortion. I sat with two different teenage friends when they got abortions, and both times we had to walk through Christians holding vile, graphic signs, hurling foul curses, and literally throwing projectiles at us. In my next essay, Christianity's Coda, I'll be talking about why I believe Christianity is in its last days as a major world religion. That aside, my fear of having to possibly get an abortion and catching a venereal disease is what ruined sex for me in this incarnation, and I don't believe waiting for The One would have made it better, especially not if I was pressured or forced to have a baby or babies I did not want. The girls I sat with in the abortion clinic did NOT want to be there and I would be shocked if they did it twice. Both had abusive families and both had used double/combo prophylactics. One was 17 and the other was 18. In previous generations, these were the exact kind of young ladies who would have been shunted to someplace far away to have their children in a baby mill. Once at the mill, these women would be marooned from everyone they knew, casually abused by Christian do-gooders like the prideful Filipino doctor who brought me into the world, and then scolded and told of how unfit they were for motherhood despite the fact their grandmothers and great grandmothers started bearing children in their teens. It didn't matter if they decided they wanted the child come what may, NOPE, the for profit baby mill would have its product, no going back. Personally I would have taken my chances with a back alley abortionist, or just killed myself and saved everyone the trouble.
Some women find sex to be extremely fulfilling and wonderful, and as far as being portrayed as objects, as long as people are consenting adults, I say good for them. I enjoyed sex during the key parts of my marriage, but the damage of being terrified during my formative years left deep scars and chronic UTIs from condom use. Now that my husband and I are 22 years into our marriage, we have a relationship much like what you would expect of a loving, older couple. I wish I had been born an asexual because that would have been easier than dealing with a normal sex drive in a culture that was ¡¡¡VIRGIN WHORE VIRGIN WHORE VIRGIN WHORE!!! all the time.
I would like to see Christians act more like Jesus and instead of trying to change people's minds, to help them actually change their lives. That's why if I was a Christian, I wouldn't give a dime to a support crisis pregnancy charity but instead would give to a homeless shelter or a food pantry. It makes more sense to feed a homeless mom and her kid or one who is struggling to keep food on the table than to fund the paycheck of a counselor who will attempt to convince a woman to bear an unwanted baby. When we are realistic about outcomes, if the mom keeps her child, they'll probably be poor because the State does not do much for single moms, and even if it did, it would have to keep up with inflation. Let's say the kid was like me and went to be fodder for the adoption mill. That's still a crappy outcome and the mother's story in the link I left above may offer some explanation. Adoption agencies are always for-profit baby brokers to this very day, BTW, the one I was born into was neither special nor unique.
Less complicated just to feed and shelter the ones who are already here, I think.
no subject
Date: 2022-04-30 04:44 pm (UTC)